In 2023, a Colombian court set a precedent by employing an AI ‘metaverse judge’ to overstep a virtual court case, signaling a radical use of futuristic technology. In this new trend, the tech industry partners with the justice system, giving rise to a blend of optimism and caution worldwide.
“Artificial Justice,” a political sci-fi thriller directed by Simón Casal, stretches the concept of AI in the justice system, delving into its ominous consequences. The plot unravels in a futuristic Spain where the public is preparing to vote in a historic national referendum. The question being asked is whether to replace human judges in court with an AI software named THENTE.
THENTE embodies an advanced and effective legal tool. Its capabilities include facial recognition to predict a suspect’s guilt, truthfulness during interrogation, and even the chance of reoffending. However, this equally under the algorithm is questioned by the audience and the characters alike.
At the heart of the narrative is Judge Carmen Costa, who faces conflicting challenges to either support the government and THENTE or ally with a group of genuine judges advocating for human judicial authority. Her reluctance to back THENTE mirrors present concerns around AI, including its preconceived biases, ethics, and hallucinations.
Running parallel to big tech corporations, like Sam Altmans, THENTE and its staff represent advocates for technology. They passionately argue for the potential of technology in eliminating human error and eventually superseding human function.
Although the film stimulates thought, its conclusion brings disappointment, leaving audiences in suspense about the referendum’s result, the operational aspect of self-driving cars’ satellites, and the role of Bitcoin as a future method of payment in the AI landscape.
Despite these gaps, “Artificial Justice” is a timely and captivating film. It is currently being featured at the 2024 Spanish Film Festival in Australia, which runs from June 14 to July 10, presented by Palace Cinemas.
In essence, “Artificial Justice” examines a future with AI’s influence on pivotal democratic pillars. Amid opting for an allegiance to the government-backed AI or a steadfast group of human judges, the plot underscores the growing fascination with and apprehension against AI’s emergence in the justice system. With a narrative reflecting prevailing AI-induced anxieties, the movie offers a thought-provoking glimpse into the future of technology and its potential intersection with human society and ethics.
